How to Break Free from the Mom Comparison Trap on Social Media
Takeaway: The mom comparison trap is real—and it can quietly fuel anxiety and self-doubt in early motherhood. If you’ve ever wondered why other moms seem to “do it better,” you’re not alone. In this post, you’ll find both compassion and concrete strategies to reshape your relationship with social media, trust your instincts, and feel more confident in your choices as a mom.
You Are Not the Only Mom Comparing Yourself Online (Even If It Feels That Way)
When my baby was born, he slept great—just not in the way Instagram or the “Chat for Moms in My Birth Month” told me he should. He’d nap peacefully in my arms for hours, but the moment I tried to put him in the crib, it was over.
At the same time, my feed was overflowing with “sleep success stories.” Perfectly lit nurseries. Moms casually mentioning that their babies were sleeping through the night (STTN) at eight weeks. Nap schedules that belonged in spreadsheets. And, most painful of all, the subtle message that if your baby wasn’t doing these things, it was because you were doing something wrong.
I could feel the pressure creeping in—and the perfectionism. The exhaustion wasn’t just physical—it was emotional. I was pouring so much energy into trying to measure up to curated snapshots of motherhood. And here’s the truth: all moms deserve honesty. Most of those accounts don’t share what’s happening behind the scenes. The support systems they have—whether it’s a partner on parental leave, live-in grandparents, or a night nanny—are rarely part of the story.
If you’ve ever scrolled through Instagram, Pinterest, or even a mom group thread and thought, Why is she doing motherhood better than me?, you are not alone. This is the mom comparison trap on social media.
And while social media can be a source of stress, it’s also a tool—Pew Research found that 84% of parents use it as a parenting resource, with mothers turning to it slightly more often than fathers. It’s a place where we gather ideas, find community, and seek advice—but it’s also where comparison can quietly creep in, fueling stress that contributes to postpartum anxiety and postpartum depression (often grouped under Perinatal Mood and Anxiety Disorders, or PMADs).
Why the Mom Comparison Trap Hits So Hard in Early Motherhood
For many women, the comparison trap starts long before the baby arrives. If you’re trying to conceive, the internet can hit hard. There are endless forums, fertility trackers, and highlight-reel pregnancy announcements that make it feel like everyone else is getting it “right” faster than you. By the time you’re holding your baby, that pattern of comparison can already be deeply ingrained.
Society tells us that good moms “just know” how to care for their babies. That instincts will kick in the moment we need them, and we’ll coast through motherhood like it’s second nature. So when something doesn’t work the first time—or when your baby’s needs don’t match what you’ve been told—it’s easy to start wondering if you’re doing something wrong. Low self-esteem creeps in, and in that vulnerable place, comparison finds a way in.
In my therapy practice for Washington moms, I see the same social media triggers come up again and again:
Sleep – especially when other moms post about babies “sleeping through the night” early on.
Body image and bounce-back culture – the pressure to look like pregnancy never happened.
Milestone checklists – posts that make it seem like all babies should be on the same timetable.
Feeding choices – breastfeeding vs. formula, or when and how to introduce solids.
Discipline styles – conflicting advice that sparks quiet self-doubt.
These aren’t just “educational” posts—they’re pressure points. And when they pile up, they can make even a confident mom second-guess herself.
Social media doesn’t cause Perinatal Mood and Anxiety Disorders (PMADs), but it can make them louder. When you’re already feeling anxious, overwhelmed, or unsure, those perfectly curated posts can make it harder to trust yourself.
Here’s what I tell my clients, over and over: You are the expert on what works for your family, and you can trust your intuition. Not the influencer with the perfect nursery. Not the stranger in your birth month group. Not the mom down the street. You.
→Learning to trust your gut and listen to yourself as a mom is a tough learning curve. If you’re struggling with this, check out my blog post that teaches you about the science behind maternal intuition and how to gain confidence in your ability to make the best decisions for your family here.
The Mental Health Impact of the Comparison Trap
As a perinatal therapist, I see comparison impact some moms more than others—especially those with high-functioning anxiety, a history of perfectionism, and a track record of being high performers. Motherhood can feel like the ultimate challenge to “win,” and social media makes it easy to believe that if you just try harder, you can get there.
That often looks like staying up late researching baby sleep schedules, scrolling for hours trying to find the “right” answer, or feeling intense frustration when the advice you find online doesn’t work for your baby. The pressure builds, the self-doubt grows, and before long, comparison isn’t just an occasional thought—it’s an everyday stressor.
For some moms, this cycle can feed into postpartum anxiety or postpartum depression. These are both part of a larger group of conditions called Perinatal Mood and Anxiety Disorders, and they often overlap. The important thing to know is that they are treatable—and that needing help is not a sign you’ve failed. In fact, with the right support, many moms start to feel relief quickly.
Social media isn’t the cause of postpartum mental health struggles, but it can make them louder. When you’re already feeling overwhelmed, the constant highlight reels and curated mom-life posts can amplify the belief that you’re not doing enough. And when you’re perfectionistic by nature, the temptation to “research your way out” of the problem can turn into doomscrolling—a cycle that rarely brings the peace or clarity you’re looking for
You deserve to feel confident in your choices without having to measure them against a filtered feed. And you deserve to know that if you’re struggling, it’s not your fault—and you don’t have to keep doing it alone.
How to Step Out of the Mom Comparison Trap on Social Media
Here’s the thing: I don’t recommend quitting social media. It’s everywhere, and it does have real benefits. For many moms, Instagram or Facebook groups are where they find playdates, mom groups, or just a sense of community in those long early months. The goal isn’t to log off forever—it’s to make your experience healthier and less overwhelming.
In my work with moms (and in my own life), these are some of the steps that make the biggest difference:
Curate your feed. Spend a few days paying close attention to how you feel when you scroll. If a reel or post leaves you feeling tense, triggered, or “less than,” unfollow it. Then actively search for content you do want to see—whether that’s supportive motherhood accounts or completely unrelated topics that bring you joy. I’ve shared more on this, including my favorite respectful and drama-free mom accounts, in my blog post about curating your newsfeed with the 10 most supportive Instagram accounts for moms.
Say no to the “wrong” mom events. Not every mom group will be your people. Trying to fit in with a circle that doesn’t share your values or interests is a fast track to comparison. Instead, say yes to events or playdates that genuinely appeal to you. Think of it this way: you’re not comparing apples to apples if you’re in the wrong orchard.
Take intentional breaks. Breaks don’t have to mean deleting your apps. Sometimes it’s as simple as going for a drive or taking your baby for a swim—both times where you physically can’t be on your phone. Giving yourself even short windows without scrolling can quiet some of the noise.
Use a timer. If you want to stay connected but not get sucked in, set a limit. Give yourself 15 minutes of scrolling, then put the phone away. If you notice the doomscrolling creeping back in, I share more strategies in my blog post about how to stop doomscrolling.
These strategies to change your relationship with social media are not about doing motherhood perfectly. They’re about creating space to hear your own instincts without the constant noise of other people’s opinions.
If you’re finding that comparison is overwhelming your day-to-day, therapy can be a safe place to sort through it. Support doesn’t mean you’re failing—it means you’re giving yourself the same care you give your baby.
Perinatal Therapy for Washington Moms Who Feel Stuck in the Comparison Trap
Motherhood is overwhelming enough without the pressure of measuring yourself against every post, reel, or checklist online. When you’re already tired and stretched thin, comparison can sneak in and convince you that you’re not doing enough—when in reality, you’re doing the best you can with what you have.
You don’t have to carry that weight by yourself.
I’m a perinatal therapist for Washington moms navigating the messy middle of pregnancy, postpartum, and early motherhood. Whether you’re comparing baby sleep, milestones, or simply the version of motherhood you imagined versus the one you’re living—your story deserves space to be heard without judgment.
Therapy can give you a place to quiet the noise of social media, reconnect with your instincts, and feel supported in the choices that actually work for your family.
→ If you’re a mom in Seattle, Bellevue, Bainbridge Island, Kitsap County, or anywhere across Washington State, click here to schedule your free intro call today. No pressure—just a chance to connect and see if we’re a fit.
You deserve support from a therapist who truly gets where you are. I’m here for you when you’re ready.
Not looking for therapy right now?
You can still get support and encouragement through my other resources for women in the perinatal period:
→ Through Thick and Thin Newsletter – resources for moms straight to your inbox
→ Free Mental Health Resources for Moms- 100% free downloadable guides and worksheets for moms
→ The Sisterhood Blog – more articles like this one + interviews of other perinatal providers in Washington State
→ Instagram – daily encouragement and connection that’s just for women who want real support
THROUGH THICK AND THIN NEWSLETTERJoin the Sisterhood!
The monthly newsletter that’s made for moms. Get mom’s mental health info, tips to make parenting easier, and spotlights on professionals who take care of women and new moms in Washington State,,, because we could all use a bigger village and the wisdom it offers.
